Presbyterians have been worshiping in Carndonagh since the 1690’s. The current church hall was used for worship until 1886 when the present Church building was completed.
Below is a list of ministers (compiled by Mildred Lappin) who served at Hillhead.

Mr Robert Neilson (probationer)

Rev Thomas Harvey

Rev Shom Strawbridge

Rev Henry Mc Kinley

Rev Robert Scott

Rev Reuben Rodgers

Rev Robert Long Rodgers

Rev Alex Pinkerton

Rev Robert Morrison

Rev Heaney Boyd

Rev Roy Alexander

Rev Henry Mc Neilly

Rev. Dr. John Lappin

Rev David Hagan

1695-1698

1701-1718

1721-1762

1766-1768

1777-1803

1808-1843

1844-1847

1847-1884

1884-1925

1928-1969

1976-1979

1979-1982

1983-2000

2000--present